Santullo's Eatery

They have a $2/slice special between 4-6. I get on line before 6 and didn't get to order until afterwards because their credit card machine goes down. After paying $9+ for a cheese slice, a pepperoni slice and a soda, I state my case for a $2 slice. The cashier's response was that the computer controls the price and, "well, that's just too bad." 5 minutes later, I find that my pizza wasn't even in the oven yet! The only thing that kept me sane was knowing that I'll never have to go back in there again. On top of that, there was a poor lady who asked for the orange soda at the fountain to be fixed. I ate my pizza at the restaurant and didn't see anyone go to look at it. Miserable experience aside, the pizza wasn't terrible. It doesn't compare to the pizza in NY and it is pricey for a slice. If I wasn't treated like crap, would have maybe considered going back.

This place has great deals! Not to mention the 2.75 frosty mugs of beer YUM! Great music, and the staff is really chill!

This pizza is the best in Bucktown. I stumbled into here after seeing and tasting how over rated PIECE is. Santullo's has some the best cheese offered in the city. This is very tasty pizza! And the atmosphere is relaxing because of the urban staff. You'll see what I mean - just go check it out.

As someone who's not too fond of Chicago-style pizza, I was happy to find this great restaurant. I think the value's good-big slices, enough choices of toppings.

pizza is mediocre and overpriced. 2 slices and a drink will cost you over 10 bucks